To replace a broken tile soap dish in a shower, carefully remove the damaged tile using a chisel and hammer. Then, apply adhesive to the back of the new soap dish tile and press it into place firmly.
A broken tile soap dish in a shower can be unsightly and inconvenient. Luckily, replacing it is a simple DIY project that can be done with just a few tools and materials. In this guide, we will walk you through the step-by-step process of removing the old tile and installing a new one to restore the functionality and aesthetics of your shower space.
With these easy instructions, you can have your shower looking as good as new in no time.
Common Causes Of Broken Tile Soap Dishes
Tile soap dishes in showers are a functional and aesthetic feature in many bathrooms, but they can be prone to damage. Understanding the common causes of broken tile soap dishes can help you identify potential issues early and take preventative measures to maintain both the functionality and appearance of your bathroom.

1. Improper Installation
One of the leading causes of broken tile soap dishes is improper installation. Soap dishes need to be securely anchored to the wall, often using specialized adhesive or screws. If not installed correctly, they may not bond adequately to the tile or wall surface, leading to instability over time.
2. Excessive Weight or Pressure
Tile soap dishes are designed to hold soap, but when used to support heavier items, such as shampoo bottles or as a grab handle, the added weight or pressure can cause them to loosen or crack. This misuse is particularly common in households with limited shower storage options.
3. Thermal Expansion and Contraction
Showers experience frequent temperature changes due to hot and cold water use. Over time, this can lead to the expansion and contraction of tiles and grout. If the soap dish is rigidly attached without accommodating these movements, it can weaken the bond or cause cracks.
4. Age and Wear
Like any feature in the bathroom, soap dishes have a lifespan. Over time, exposure to water, humidity, and cleaning agents can erode the materials and adhesive, making them more susceptible to breaking or detaching.
5. Accidental Impact
Accidental impacts are another common culprit. A dropped shampoo bottle or other shower items can strike the soap dish, chipping or cracking the tile. In some cases, the impact can completely dislodge the soap dish from its mount.
6. Poor Grouting or Caulking
Grout and caulk play a critical role in holding tile soap dishes securely and preventing water from seeping behind them. Over time, grout can crack or deteriorate, and caulking can peel away, leading to instability. Water infiltration can exacerbate the problem by weakening the adhesive and causing further damage.
7. Structural Issues in the Wall
Underlying structural issues, such as rotting studs, shifting drywall, or water-damaged backer boards, can compromise the stability of a soap dish. If the wall is not sound, the tile and soap dish mounted on it are more likely to fail.
The Importance of a Functional Soap Dish in Your Bathroom
A soap dish may seem like a minor element in your bathroom, but it plays a significant role in maintaining an organized and tidy shower space. By providing a designated spot for your soap, a well-designed soap dish prevents clutter, keeps the area neat, and enhances the overall functionality and aesthetic of your shower or bathtub.
However, ensuring the durability and stability of a soap dish requires careful attention during installation and use. Below, we explore common factors that can compromise a soap dish’s functionality and provide insights on how to avoid these issues.
1. The Role of Proper Installation in Soap Dish Stability
One of the most critical aspects of a soap dish’s functionality is its installation. Incorrect installation can lead to instability, making the soap dish prone to breaking or detaching from the wall. When installing a soap dish, it’s crucial to:
- Use the appropriate adhesive or grout for the type of wall surface.
- Follow the manufacturer’s guidelines for weight limits and positioning.
- Ensure the dish is level and securely fastened to avoid wobbling or detachment over time.
2. Impact or Force Applied to the Soap Dish
A soap dish, though small, can be vulnerable to external impact or excessive force. Accidental bumps or leaning on the soap dish during showering may weaken its attachment to the wall or even cause it to break. To minimize this risk:
- Position the soap dish in a spot that is out of the way of frequent movements.
- Avoid placing it at a height where it may be accidentally grabbed for support.
3. Using Heavy or Oversized Soap Bars
Soap dishes are designed to hold regular-sized soap bars. The use of heavy or oversized bars can place unnecessary stress on the dish, especially if it is mounted on a tiled surface. Over time, this added weight may weaken the adhesive or grout holding the dish in place. To address this:
- Choose soap bars that fit comfortably within the dimensions of your soap dish.
- Consider lightweight soap alternatives or liquid soap dispensers if you regularly use larger bars.
4. Inadequate Grout or Adhesive
The longevity and stability of a soap dish depend heavily on the quality of grout or adhesive used during installation. Subpar materials may result in the dish detaching from the wall or failing to stay secure under regular use. To ensure durability:
- Invest in high-quality adhesives or grouts that are compatible with your bathroom’s materials (e.g., tile, fiberglass, or stone).
- Regularly inspect the soap dish for signs of wear, such as cracking or loosening grout, and perform repairs promptly.
Assessment
Assessment is the first step in replacing a broken tile soap dish in a shower. It involves inspecting the damage and determining the scope of work to effectively plan the replacement process.
Inspecting The Damage
Before replacing a broken tile soap dish, thoroughly inspect the damage to identify the extent of the issue. Look for cracks, loose tiles, or any other damage that may affect the soap dish installation.
Determining The Scope Of Work
Once you’ve inspected the damage, determine the scope of work required for the replacement. Consider factors such as the size of the damaged area, the type of tiles used, and any additional repairs needed.
Preparation to Replace
Preparation is key when it comes to replacing a broken tile soap dish in a shower. Before starting the project, it’s important to gather all the necessary tools and materials and take the appropriate safety precautions.
Gathering Necessary Tools And Materials
Before beginning the replacement process, gather the following tools and materials:
- Replacement tile soap dish
- Grout saw or rotary tool with grout removal attachment
- Putty knife or chisel
- Tile adhesive or thin-set mortar
- Grout
- Grout float
- Tile spacers
- Tile sponge
- Level
- Protective gloves
Safety Precautions
When replacing a broken tile soap dish in a shower, it’s important to take the following safety precautions:
- Wear protective gloves to prevent cuts from broken tiles and sharp tools.
- Use eye protection to shield your eyes from any flying debris during the removal process.
- Ensure proper ventilation in the bathroom when working with tile adhesive or grout to avoid inhaling fumes.
- Keep the work area clean and free of any obstructions to prevent accidents.
Removing the Broken Tile
To replace a broken tile soap dish in a shower, begin by removing the damaged tile carefully using a grout saw and chisel. Gently tap the chisel to avoid damaging surrounding tiles. After removing the broken tile, clean the area thoroughly to prepare for the installation of the new soap dish.
Removing The Grout Surrounding The Tile
The first step in removing the broken tile soap dish is to remove the grout surrounding it. Here’s how to do it:
- Use a grout removal tool or a small chisel to carefully chip away at the grout around the broken tile. Be sure not to damage the surrounding tiles.
- Once you’ve removed the bulk of the grout, use a utility knife to carefully cut away any remaining bits of grout or adhesive. This will help loosen the broken tile from the wall.
- Use a putty knife or scraper to gently pry the broken tile away from the wall. Be careful not to damage the surrounding tiles.
Taking Out The Broken Tile
Now that you’ve removed the grout surrounding the broken tile, it’s time to take out the broken tile itself. Here’s how:
- Use a hammer and chisel to carefully break the broken tile into smaller pieces. Be sure to wear eye protection and work gloves to protect yourself from flying debris.
- Once you’ve broken the tile into small pieces, use a putty knife or scraper to remove the pieces from the wall.
- Use a scraper or sandpaper to smooth out any remaining bits of grout or adhesive on the wall.
Recommended Post: How to Remodel a Shower Stall With Tile
Installing the Replacement Tile Soap Dish
When replacing a broken tile soap dish in a shower, proper installation is key to ensuring a seamless and long-lasting repair. Here, we’ll walk through the steps of preparing the area for the new tile, as well as applying adhesive and setting the replacement tile.

Preparing The Area For The New Tile
Before installing the replacement tile soap dish, it’s essential to remove any remaining debris and ensure the area is clean and dry. Use a putty knife to carefully chip away the old adhesive and grout, taking care not to damage the surrounding tiles. Once the area is clear, wipe it down with a damp cloth to remove any remaining residue and allow it to dry completely.
Applying Adhesive And Setting The Replacement Tile
Using a notched trowel, apply a thin layer of tile adhesive to the back of the replacement tile soap dish. Press the tile firmly into place, ensuring it is level and flush with the surrounding tiles. Allow the adhesive to set according to the manufacturer’s instructions before applying grout to the seams between the tiles. Use a grout float to pack the grout into the seams, then wipe away any excess with a damp sponge.
Recommended Read: Install Shower Pan Over Existing Tile Floor!
Grouting the Tile
When it comes to replacing a broken tile soap dish in a shower, grouting is a crucial step in the process. Grouting not only helps secure the new soap dish in place but also provides a polished and finished look to the entire repair. Proper grouting ensures that the tiles are sealed, preventing water from seeping in and causing damage.

Applying Grout To The Tile Gaps
Before applying grout, it’s important to ensure that the tile adhesive has fully set. Once the adhesive is dry, mix the grout according to the manufacturer’s instructions. Using a rubber float, apply the grout to the tile gaps, ensuring that each gap is completely filled. Work in small sections to prevent the grout from drying out before it is properly applied.
Cleaning Excess Grout
After the grout has been applied and has set for a few minutes, use a damp sponge to wipe away the excess grout from the tile surface. Be sure to clean the grout lines thoroughly, removing any excess grout to achieve a clean and polished look. After the initial cleaning, allow the grout to dry for the recommended time before giving the tiles a final buff with a dry cloth to remove any remaining haze.
Finishing Touches
Replacing a broken tile soap dish in a shower can be a daunting task, but with the right tools and some basic knowledge, it can be done easily and quickly. In the previous sections, we have covered how to remove the old soap dish and install a new one. In this section, we will discuss the finishing touches that will ensure your new soap dish looks great and functions properly for years to come.

Sealing The Grout
Once you have installed the new soap dish, it’s important to seal the grout around it. This will prevent water from seeping behind the tiles and causing damage to the wall or the soap dish itself. You can use a silicone-based grout sealer to seal the grout lines. Make sure to apply the sealer evenly and wipe away any excess with a clean cloth. Allow the sealer to dry for at least 24 hours before using the shower.
Final Inspection
Before you start using the shower again, take a few minutes to inspect your work. Check the soap dish to make sure it is level and securely in place. Give the tiles a gentle tap to make sure they are all firmly adhered to the wall. Look for any gaps or spaces between the tiles and the soap dish and fill them with grout if necessary. Finally, clean up any excess grout or debris from the installation process.
Replacing a broken tile soap dish in a shower may seem like a daunting task, but with the right tools and knowledge, it can be done easily and quickly. Follow the steps we have outlined in this post and you’ll be on your way to a beautiful and functional new soap dish in no time.
Conclusion
Ensuring your shower soap dish is intact is key to a functional bathroom. By following these simple steps, you can easily replace a broken tile soap dish yourself. Don’t let a damaged soap dish dampen your shower experience; tackle the task confidently and enjoy a refreshed bathroom space.