Ice and water shield is a self-adhering roofing underlayment designed to protect against moisture damage. It creates a waterproof barrier that prevents leaks caused by ice dams and wind-driven rain. While highly effective, removing it can be difficult due to its strong adhesive backing.
Homeowners and roofing professionals may need to remove ice and water shield for several reasons, such as roof repairs, replacement, or improper installation. The challenge lies in detaching it without damaging the roof deck, as the material bonds tightly to the surface over time.
This guide explains the best methods to remove ice and water shield safely, including cutting, applying heat, and using the right tools. It also covers common challenges, expert tips, and how to prepare the roof for new underlayment. Following these steps helps ensure a smooth removal process while protecting the integrity of the roof structure.
How to Remove Ice and Water Shield From Roof – Step-by-Step Guide
Removing ice and water shield requires patience and the right approach to avoid damaging the roof deck. The material’s strong adhesive makes the process challenging, but following a step-by-step method ensures effective removal with minimal risk.
Step 1: Assess the Roof and Prepare for Removal
Before starting, inspect the roof to determine the condition of the ice and water shield and the extent of removal required. In some cases, only a portion needs to be removed, while for a full roof replacement, all of it must be taken off.
Safety is a priority. Roofing work involves heights, so using proper fall protection gear is essential. Wear a harness, non-slip boots, and gloves to maintain a secure grip. Plan the removal on a dry day since wet surfaces increase the risk of slipping.
Gather the necessary tools for removal:
- A roofing knife or utility knife to cut through the material
- A heat gun or roofing torch to loosen the adhesive
- A pry bar for lifting edges
- A scraper or putty knife to remove residual adhesive
- Mineral spirits or adhesive remover for stubborn residue
Checking the roof deck for potential weak spots is also important. Areas with signs of water damage or rot need extra care to prevent further deterioration during removal.
Step 2: Cutting and Peeling Off the Ice and Water Shield
Once the roof is prepared, start by cutting the ice and water shield into manageable sections. Using a utility knife, score the material into strips about 12 to 18 inches wide. Smaller sections are easier to lift and remove without excessive force.
Begin at an exposed edge or corner where the material is loose. If there is no obvious starting point, carefully lift a section using a pry bar. Peel the membrane slowly, applying steady pressure to avoid tearing. Some areas may come off easily, while others will require additional effort.
If the shield resists removal, avoid pulling too hard, as this can damage the plywood sheathing underneath. Instead, move to another section and return to the difficult spots later, especially once the heat is applied.
Step 3: Using Heat to Loosen the Adhesive
Ice and water shield has a self-adhering backing that bonds tightly to the roof deck, making heat an effective solution for softening the adhesive. Using a heat gun or roofing torch, apply heat to a small section at a time.
Hold the heat source a few inches away from the surface and move it in a steady motion. The goal is to warm the adhesive just enough to loosen its grip without scorching the roofing material. Excessive heat can cause damage, especially to the wood decking beneath.
After heating, attempt to peel back the material again. In most cases, it will come off with significantly less effort than before. If the adhesive remains stubborn, repeat the process in sections, working from one side of the roof to the other.
Step 4: Scraping Off Residual Adhesive
Once the main sections of the ice and water shield are removed, adhesive residue often remains on the roof deck. This sticky layer can make reinstallation of new underlayment difficult, so it must be cleaned thoroughly.
Start with a scraper or putty knife, working in small motions to lift as much residue as possible. If the adhesive is still too strong, applying a solvent-based adhesive remover or mineral spirits can help dissolve it.
Pour a small amount onto a clean cloth and rub it over the sticky areas. Allow it to sit for a few minutes, then use the scraper again. This method helps loosen even the toughest adhesive without damaging the wood surface.
After removing the residue, wipe the surface with a damp cloth to remove any remaining solvent. Allow the area to dry completely before moving to the next step.
Step 5: Inspecting and Repairing the Roof Deck
After the old ice and water shield is fully removed, inspect the roof deck for damage. Look for water stains, rot, or warped wood, as these are signs that sections may need replacement before new underlayment is installed.
If the plywood is in good condition but has minor imperfections, sanding rough spots can create a smooth surface for the new material. For more serious damage, replacing sections of the decking ensures the roof remains structurally sound.
Check that the deck is completely dry before installing new roofing materials. Moisture trapped under new underlayment can lead to mold growth and deterioration over time. If needed, allow the deck to air out for a few hours before proceeding.
Once the surface is smooth and free of debris, it is ready for a new ice and water shield or an alternative underlayment. Proper installation techniques will ensure the new barrier performs effectively and lasts for years.
Common Challenges & Expert Tips for Easier Removal
Removing ice and water shield can be a difficult and time-consuming task due to its strong adhesive properties and durability. Several factors, such as age, weather exposure, and the condition of the roof deck, can impact the removal process. Understanding these challenges and applying expert techniques can make the job easier and more efficient.
Challenges in Removing Ice and Water Shield
Strong Adhesive Bond
Ice and water shield is designed to adhere tightly to the roof deck, preventing leaks and moisture infiltration. However, this same property makes it extremely difficult to remove once it has been installed for several years. The adhesive forms a permanent bond with the plywood, making peeling it off a strenuous process.
Risk of Roof Deck Damage
Pulling up the underlayment too aggressively can cause delamination or splintering of the plywood decking. In some cases, parts of the wood may come off along with the membrane, leading to costly repairs or the need for deck replacement.
Brittle or Tear-Prone Material
If the ice and water shield is old or has been exposed to extreme temperature changes, it can become brittle. Instead of peeling off in large sections, it may break into small pieces, making the process tedious and time-consuming.
Stubborn Residual Adhesive
Even after removing the main membrane, a layer of sticky residue often remains on the roof deck. This adhesive buildup can interfere with the installation of new underlayment, making it necessary to remove it completely before proceeding with roofing work.
Temperature-Related Difficulties
Cold weather causes the ice and water shield to become rigid, making it even harder to lift and remove. On the other hand, hot weather can make the adhesive extra sticky, increasing the risk of tearing and leaving excessive residue behind.
Expert Tips for Easier Removal
Work in Warm Weather or Apply Heat
Removing ice and water shield is much easier when the material is soft and flexible. If possible, schedule removal on a warm day when outdoor temperatures are above 50°F (10°C). If working in cooler conditions, use a heat gun or roofing torch to gently warm up the material before attempting to peel it off. This loosens the adhesive and prevents tearing.
Cut the Shield Into Small Sections
Rather than trying to remove large sheets at once, use a roofing knife or utility knife to cut the membrane into strips 12 to 18 inches wide. This reduces resistance and makes it easier to handle smaller pieces, preventing excessive strain on the roof deck.
Use a Pry Bar for Initial Lifting
If the edges of the ice and water shield are fully bonded to the deck, use a flat pry bar to carefully lift the corners before pulling. This gives better leverage and helps avoid tearing the material while keeping the plywood intact.
Apply a Solvent for Residual Adhesive
For areas with stubborn adhesive residue, use mineral spirits or an adhesive remover to break down the sticky layer. Apply a small amount to the affected area, let it sit for a few minutes, and then use a scraper to remove the softened adhesive. This method minimizes the risk of damaging the wood deck.
Maintain a Steady and Controlled Pulling Motion
When peeling back the ice and water shield, apply slow and even pressure rather than pulling too quickly. Rapid force can cause tearing, leaving behind small pieces that are harder to remove. A steady motion helps lift the membrane more smoothly.
Use a Roofing Torch for Large Stubborn Sections
For large areas where the shield refuses to budge, a roofing torch can be an effective solution. Carefully heat a section for 10 to 15 seconds, then peel it back while the adhesive is still warm. Be cautious not to overheat the surface, as excessive heat can damage the wood.
Also Read: Remove Chimney Stack above Roof Line
Preventing Future Issues with Ice and Water Shield
Properly handling ice and water shield during removal and replacement can prevent future roofing issues, such as leaks, poor adhesion, or deck damage. Homeowners and contractors should understand when to replace the underlayment, how to install it correctly, and what alternative solutions may work better for their specific roofing needs.
When to Replace or Reinstall Ice and Water Shield
After Major Roof Repairs or Replacement
Whenever a roof undergoes significant repairs or a full replacement, it is crucial to install a new ice and water shield layer. Reusing old underlayment is not advisable, as the adhesive backing loses effectiveness once removed. Freshly installed material ensures proper waterproofing and long-term protection.
If the Existing Ice and Water Shield Is Damaged
During removal, the membrane may tear or become brittle, making it impossible to reinstall. Additionally, age, UV exposure, and trapped moisture can weaken the material over time. If the underlayment shows signs of deterioration, such as cracking, curling, or adhesive failure, replacement is necessary to maintain roof integrity.
Before Installing New Shingles Over an Aged Roof Deck
If a new layer of shingles is being installed over an older roof deck, a fresh ice and water shield should be applied. Over time, the old underlayment may have lost its adhesion and sealing capabilities, making it ineffective in preventing water infiltration. Adding a new barrier helps protect vulnerable areas like valleys, eaves, and flashing points.
When Upgrading to a More Advanced Underlayment
Modern roofing technologies offer improved ice and water shield products with better adhesion, flexibility, and durability. If a roof has a standard self-adhering underlayment, homeowners may choose to upgrade to a high-temperature-resistant or synthetic version for superior performance in extreme weather conditions.
Alternatives to Ice and Water Shield
While ice and water shield is an effective moisture barriers, certain roofing situations may require alternative underlayment materials. Some homeowners and contractors prefer different products based on climate, budget, and specific roofing designs.
Synthetic Roofing Underlayment
Synthetic underlayment, made from polypropylene or polyester-based materials, is a lightweight and durable option that provides better tear resistance and UV protection than traditional felt paper. It is commonly used in modern roofing systems and offers excellent water resistance without excessive adhesion, making future removal easier.
Traditional Roofing Felt (Tar Paper)
Roofing felt, or tar paper, has been used for decades as a water-resistant barrier. While not as adhesive or durable as ice and water shield, it still provides a protective layer between the shingles and roof deck. It is a more budget-friendly option but requires proper overlapping and fasteners to maintain its effectiveness.
Peel-and-Stick Synthetic Underlayment
This is a hybrid solution that combines some benefits of ice and water shield with synthetic underlayment. It offers a self-adhering surface without being overly aggressive, making it easier to remove when necessary while still providing strong waterproofing capabilities.
Rubberized Asphalt Underlayment
Similar to traditional ice and water shield but more flexible, rubberized asphalt underlayment is designed for high-temperature environments and offers enhanced adhesion. It is a good choice for metal roofs or areas prone to extreme heat, as it resists softening and damage caused by high temperatures.
Liquid Applied Waterproofing Membrane
For flat or low-slope roofs, a liquid-applied membrane can serve as an effective alternative. This type of waterproofing solution creates a seamless, fully adhered barrier that prevents water penetration without the need for adhesive-backed sheets.
Choosing the Right Underlayment for Long-Term Protection
Selecting the best underlayment depends on climate conditions, roof design, and homeowner preferences. Ice and water shield remains one of the most reliable solutions for preventing leaks, but alternative options can provide easier removal, cost savings, or enhanced performance based on specific needs.
You May Also Like: Roof Leaking Where Porch Meets House
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Why is ice and water shield so difficult to remove?
Ice and water shield is designed for strong adhesion to prevent water infiltration. Its self-sealing properties create a watertight bond with the roof deck, making removal difficult, especially after long-term exposure to heat, cold, and moisture. Over time, the adhesive can harden, making peeling it off a labor-intensive process.
Can I reuse ice and water shield after removing it?
No, ice and water shield cannot be reused. Once removed, its adhesive backing loses effectiveness, making it unreliable for reinstallation. Additionally, the material may tear or stretch during removal, reducing its ability to provide a watertight seal.
Does heating the ice and water shield make removal easier?
Yes, applying heat softens the adhesive, making it easier to peel off the underlayment without excessive tearing. A heat gun or propane torch can be used carefully to warm the material but avoid overheating, as this can damage the roof deck.
Can I install new shingles without removing the old ice and water shield?
It depends on the condition of the existing underlayment. If it is smooth, intact, and securely adhered, new shingles may be installed over it. However, if it is damaged, bubbling, or deteriorating, it should be removed and replaced to ensure a flat and stable roofing surface.
How often should ice and water shield be replaced?
Ice and water shields typically last 20 to 30 years, depending on the climate and roof conditions. It should be replaced if it becomes brittle, damaged, or loses adhesion, or whenever a full roof replacement is performed.
Does removing ice and water shield damage the roof deck?
If removed improperly, the adhesive can pull up wood fibers from the roof deck, leading to surface damage. Using heat and carefully scraping off residual adhesive can help minimize damage. If sections of the deck are compromised, they should be repaired before new underlayment is installed.
Conclusion
Removing ice and water shield from a roof can be a challenging task due to its strong adhesive properties. However, with proper tools, techniques, and preparation, it can be done efficiently without causing significant damage to the roof deck. Assessing the roof, applying heat to loosen the adhesive, carefully scraping off residue, and inspecting the deck for repairs are key steps to ensure a successful removal process.
Homeowners should also consider when to replace or reinstall ice and water shield to maintain long-term roof protection. In some cases, alternative underlayment options such as synthetic or rubberized asphalt materials may be better suited for specific roofing needs.
Whether tackling the project as a DIY task or hiring a professional, following best practices ensures that the roof remains structurally sound and protected against moisture infiltration. Proper maintenance, timely replacements, and choosing the right materials will help prevent future issues, prolonging the lifespan of the roofing system and enhancing overall home durability.
